Sufficient Cause I Sufficient Cause 1 Sufficient Cause
نویسنده
چکیده
The conceptual framework for causes presented here is intended neither as a review nor an expansion of knowledge, but rather as a viewpoint which bridges the gap between metaphysical notions of cause and basic epidemiologic parameters. The focus, then, is neither metaphysics nor epidemiology, but the gulf between them. In the same spirit as recent discussion on these pages about definitions of basic epidemiologic terms such as rate (1), common agreement on the conceptual interrelationship of causes may facilitate communication about causes of illness. A strong motivation for presenting this scheme is the often-heard confusion of two important but distinct epidemiologic issues: confounding and effect modification. These two properties of variables have different areas of relevance (2). The confounding property is not an intrinsic characteristic of any variable. Confounding, defined as distortion in an effect measure introduced by an extraneous variate, occurs only in the context of a particular study, und the same variable which confounds in one study may not confound the same association in another study setting.
منابع مشابه
Sharp bounds on sufficient-cause interactions under the assumption of no redundancy
BACKGROUND Sufficient-cause interaction is a type of interaction that has received much attention recently. The sufficient component cause model on which the sufficient-cause interaction is based is however a non-identifiable model. Estimating the interaction parameters from the model is mathematically impossible. METHODS In this paper, I derive bounding formulae for sufficient-cause interact...
متن کاملStochastic counterfactuals and stochastic sufficient causes.
Most work in causal inference concerns deterministic counterfactuals; the literature on stochastic counterfactuals is small. In the stochastic counterfactual setting, the outcome for each individual under each possible set of exposures follows a probability distribution so that for any given exposure combination, outcomes vary not only between individuals but also probabilistically for each par...
متن کاملPractice of Epidemiology Marginal Structural Models for Sufficient Cause Interactions
Sufficient cause interactions concern cases in which there is a particular causal mechanism for some outcome that requires the presence of 2 or more specific causes to operate. Empirical conditions have been derived to test for sufficient cause interactions. However, when regression outcome models are used to control for confounding variables in tests for sufficient cause interactions, the outc...
متن کاملThe Counterfactual Analysis of Cause
David Lewis’s counterfactual analysis of cause consisted of the counterfactual conditional closed under transitivity.2 Namely, a sufficient condition for A’s being a cause of C is that ∼A>∼C be true; and a necessary as well as sufficient condition is that there be a series of true counterfactuals ∼A>∼E1, ∼E1 >∼E2, . . . , ∼En >∼C (n> 0). At the core of this analysis, cause is taken to be transi...
متن کاملRedundant causation from a sufficient cause perspective
Sufficient causes of disease are redundant when an individual acquires the components of two or more sufficient causes. In this circumstance, the individual still would have become diseased even if one of the sufficient causes had not been acquired. In the context of a study, when any individuals acquire components of more than one sufficient cause over the observation period, the etiologic eff...
متن کامل